Embark Studios Apologizes for Replacing The Finals Esports Casters With AI Voices in Deleted Recap
Embark Studios has taken down a highlight video from a recent esports tournament for The Finals after a wave of backlash from the human casters it replaced with the game’s AI commentators. The studio has since apologized, calling the decision a mistake, and says two more recaps planned in the same format won’t go out as scheduled.
What Happened
The deleted video recapped the APAC Closed Qualifiers for The Grand Major, an official tournament for The Finals. The casters who actually called the matches were human, but the recap Embark built from the broadcast footage used Scotty and June, the game’s fictional AI commentators, instead, with new lines written and generated for the clips.
Caster Proto, who goes by Kai, said he and fellow casters TheeHyperactive and Bluepanda had worked four cycles of open and closed qualifiers before being left out of the video, with the AI commentators even echoing lines the human casters had originally said on air. Bluepanda added that after years of being told their work was valued, they were ultimately told it wasn’t needed for the recap.
Casters and Rivals React
The response from the broader esports scene was sharply critical. League of Legends caster Initialise called the move dystopian, Marvel Rivals caster LemonKiwi said real casters deserve better, and fighting game commentator Damascus described training AI on the voices of working casters as devious. Proto called the whole situation a shitshow and argued the episode shows why esports talent, including casters and production staff, need protections such as a union or contract terms banning the use of their voices in generative AI going forward.

A rooftop firefight in The Finals, the Embark Studios shooter at the center of the AI casting controversy.
Embark’s Apology, and a Pattern With AI
Oscar Lundberg, who leads competitive experience and community work at Embark, apologized on his personal social media account, saying the recap left out the casters and talent who made the event and calling it a mistake. He confirmed the video won’t return in that form and that the AMER and EMEA recaps planned for the same rollout are being rethought. Embark separately told press that introducing more casual viewers to The Finals esports scene was the goal, but that replacing the casters wasn’t the right call.
Some casters remained unconvinced by the apology. Bluepanda said the studio only backed down after overwhelming backlash and argued that doesn’t amount to being truly sorry, adding they’re done working in the game’s esports scene. The incident follows Embark’s decision last month to add an AI-driven dynamic commentary feature to The Finals, and the studio has also defended using AI-generated voice lines in its other shooter, Arc Raiders, where it has argued recording every possible variation of in-game dialogue with human actors would be impractical.
Keep the adventure going! Check out more Gaming News on Gamersuniverse.
Picture Source: Embark Studios
