Thief Story Explained: Garrett, the Keepers, the Trickster and the Full Timeline Before Thief Remastered
Thief: The Dark Project Remastered arrives on December 3, and for many players it will be the first time they sneak through the City with Garrett. Before you pick up the blackjack, here we have Thief story explained from start to finish: who Garrett is, who the Keepers, Hammerites and Pagans are, what happens with the Trickster, Father Karras and the Hag, how the 2014 reboot and Thief VR fit in, and where the new expansion The Tarnished Mirror slots into the timeline.
We stick to what the games show, mark developer statements as such and clearly label interpretations as speculation. For the remaster and its new expansion, read our news post Thief: The Dark Project Remastered’s New Expansion Is Made by the Black Parade Mod Team.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning ⚠️ This article spoils the full stories of Thief: The Dark Project, Thief II: The Metal Age, Thief: Deadly Shadows and Thief (2014), including their endings.
🧾 Quick Facts: The Thief Story at a Glance
- Hero: Garrett, a cynical master thief trained by the secretive Keepers, voiced by Stephen Russell in the original trilogy and by Romano Orzari in the 2014 reboot
- Setting: the City, a dark fantasy metropolis that mixes medieval culture with steam technology, electric light and magic
- Factions: the neutral Keepers, the Order of the Hammer (Hammerites) and the Pagans, plus the Mechanists from Thief II onwards
- Original trilogy: The Dark Project (1998), The Metal Age (2000) and Deadly Shadows (2004)
- Later games: Thief (2014), a reboot set centuries later, and Thief VR: Legacy of Shadow (2025), set between the trilogy and the reboot
- Next: Thief: The Dark Project Remastered by Nightdive Studios on December 3, 2026, with the new four-mission expansion The Tarnished Mirror
🌆 The City and Its Factions: Thief Lore Explained
Every Thief game takes place in a metropolis known only as the City. It feels like a mix of a late medieval town and Victorian London: there are nobles, guards with swords and bows, crumbling cathedrals and haunted ruins, but also electric lights, steam machinery and magic. Project director Greg LoPiccolo once described it as an undefined medieval age crossed with films like Brazil and The City of Lost Children. Much of the lore is never explained directly; you piece it together from notes, books and conversations you overhear while hiding in the shadows.
Three powers shape the City in the original games:
- The Keepers: a secret, neutral order that watches over the balance between order and chaos. They are masters of stealth, guard ancient knowledge and read prophecies written in magical symbols called Glyphs.
- The Order of the Hammer (Hammerites): a strict religious order that worships the Builder and believes in craftsmanship, progress and righteousness. They stand for order.
- The Pagans: wild worshippers of the Trickster, a nature god who hates the stone and metal of the City. They stand for chaos.
Garrett belongs to none of them. He just wants to be left alone and get paid, but the whole trilogy is about how he keeps getting pulled into the fights between these forces, often exactly as the Keepers’ prophecies predicted.
🕵️ Who Is Garrett in Thief?
Garrett grew up as a homeless orphan on the City’s streets, living off pickpocketing. One day he tried to rob a man everyone else seemed to ignore. That man was Artemus, a Keeper, and he was impressed that the boy could even see him, since Keepers are hard to notice when they do not want to be seen. Artemus offered Garrett a place in the order, and Garrett accepted.
The Keepers trained him in their stealth arts, but Garrett eventually walked away and used those skills to become a professional thief instead. Writer and designer Ken Levine, who shaped the original story, built him as a film noir style anti-hero: cynical, sarcastic and only loyal to himself, at least on the surface. Artemus remains the one Keeper who keeps coming back for him throughout the trilogy.
👁️ Thief: The Dark Project Story Explained

Thief: The Dark Project Remastered brings the 1998 original and the Thief Gold missions to modern platforms.
Thief: The Dark Project (1998), developed by Looking Glass Studios, opens years after Garrett left the Keepers. He works as an independent thief and refuses to pay a cut to the City’s crime bosses. As punishment, the crime lord Ramirez sends assassins after him. Garrett survives, follows them back and robs Ramirez’s mansion in revenge.
That job catches the attention of Viktoria, who represents a mysterious client. She hires Garrett to steal a magical sword from Constantine, an eccentric nobleman who recently arrived in the City. Once Garrett delivers it, he learns that Constantine was the client all along: stealing his own sword was a test. Constantine then offers Garrett a fortune for a far bigger job, stealing a gemstone called the Eye from a sealed Hammerite cathedral in the abandoned, haunted Old Quarter.
The cathedral turns out to have been sealed by the Keepers to protect the City from the Trickster. To break the seal, Garrett has to collect four elemental talismans of Fire, Water, Earth and Air. In the original release, two are hidden in the Lost City, an ancient ruin buried beneath the City, and two in the Hammerite temple. The 1999 re-release Thief Gold, whose content is included in the remaster, added three extra missions and moved some talismans around, with one held by mages and another turning up at an opera house. When Garrett finally gets inside the cathedral, he discovers that its Hammerite residents were killed and turned into undead by the Eye itself.
🌿 Who Is the Trickster? The Dark Project Ending Explained
Garrett brings the Eye to Constantine, and the twist hits: Constantine is the Trickster, the Pagan god himself. Viktoria, his ally, explains that the Eye needs a real eye to work. She binds Garrett with vines and tears out his right eye, which the Trickster places on the gemstone before both vanish through a portal. Garrett is left for dead, but two Keepers free him.
While escaping Constantine’s mansion, Garrett finds the Trickster’s notes and learns his real plan, his “dark project”: he wants to use the Eye to drag the world back into a wild, primal state and wipe out the age of stone, metal and light that humanity built. Garrett turns to the Hammerites for help, only to find their temple attacked. In a refuge beneath it, Hammerite survivors give him a booby-trapped fake Eye.
Garrett descends into the Trickster’s realm and finds him in the middle of the ritual. He secretly swaps the real Eye for the fake, and the trap kills the Trickster. In the final scene, Garrett walks the streets with a mechanical replacement eye. Artemus approaches him and says the Keepers will soon be needed again. Garrett wants nothing to do with them, and the Keeper leaves him with a warning: “Beware the dawn of the metal age.”
🪞 The Tarnished Mirror: Where the New Expansion Fits

The Tarnished Mirror adds four new missions set between the first two games.
The remaster’s new expansion, The Tarnished Mirror, is built by the team behind the acclaimed 2023 fan campaign The Black Parade. Its four missions are officially described as a bridge between The Dark Project and The Metal Age. According to the official store description, the story starts after the Trickster’s defeat: Garrett feels cheated out of his reward, takes on smaller jobs again while political and ideological unrest grows in the City, and the theft of a Precursor hand mirror pulls him into a conspiracy.
Garrett’s original voice actor, Stephen Russell, has recorded new lines for the expansion. How exactly its conspiracy connects to the rise of the Mechanists in Thief II has not been revealed, so any link beyond the official “bridge” description is speculation until the remaster launches.
⚙️ Thief II: The Metal Age Story Explained
Thief II: The Metal Age (2000) takes place about a year after the first game, and Artemus’ warning comes true. A schism inside the Hammerites has created the Mechanists, a fanatical sect obsessed with technology and led by Father Karras, an unstable inventor who despises the natural world. Fun fact: Karras is also voiced by Stephen Russell. The Mechanists’ inventions arm a resurgent City Watch, while the defeated Pagans have been driven out into the wilderness and fight a guerrilla war against them.
Garrett’s trouble starts when his fence betrays him and the new sheriff, Gorman Truart, starts hunting him. The Keepers show Garrett a prophecy about the Metal Age, which he brushes off, but Artemus tips him off to a secret Mechanist meeting. There Garrett overhears Truart and Karras discussing the Servants: street people turned into obedient, masked workers. Their masks can release a red vapor that turns organic matter into rust, and Truart has promised Karras twenty victims for the project. Karras secretly records Truart on a wax cylinder to blackmail him, and Garrett steals the recording from a safe deposit box.
When Garrett goes to confront Truart, he finds the sheriff already murdered. Clues lead him to Watch officer Lieutenant Mosley, whose secret letter is carried through a portal by a wounded Pagan. Garrett follows the trail and finds Viktoria, the woman who once took his eye. She proposes an alliance against the Mechanists, and Garrett reluctantly agrees.
💀 Karras’ Plan, Viktoria’s Sacrifice and the Metal Age Ending
Viktoria sends Garrett after the mysterious Cetus Project, which turns out to be a submarine. He stows away on it to kidnap the high-ranking Mechanist Brother Cavador, and learns that Karras has been handing out Servants as gifts to the City’s nobles. Garrett then steals a Servant mask, and he and Viktoria discover the real threat: devices called Cultivators inside the masks release “rust gas”, which triggers a chain reaction in organic material. Placed in noble homes with lush gardens, the Servants could start a catastrophe that would destroy the City’s plant life and everything around it.
Viktoria comes up with a desperate counterplan: lure all the Servants into the sealed Mechanist cathedral, fill it with plants and let Karras’ own gas consume him. Garrett calls it suicide and leaves. Viktoria goes alone and is killed while filling the cathedral with plants. Garrett finishes her plan during the final mission at the Soulforge, and Karras dies in his own rust gas. Afterwards Artemus tells him that Karras’ scheme and Viktoria’s death were foretold. Shaken, Garrett demands to know what else the prophecies say, and the game ends.
🌑 Thief: Deadly Shadows Story Explained

Thief: Deadly Shadows closes Garrett’s original story with a conspiracy inside the Keepers.
Thief: Deadly Shadows (2004), developed by Ion Storm with many Looking Glass veterans, finally gives Garrett what he asked for: access to the Keepers’ prophecies. In exchange, Artemus wants him to steal two artifacts, the Builder’s Chalice from the Hammerites and the Jacknall’s Paw from the Pagans. Garrett learns of a coming Dark Age, steals an ancient book called the Compendium of Reproach and a third artifact, the Kurshok Crown. The book’s prophecy says an “evil one” will be revealed when time ceases to exist. Garrett reads that as the City’s clocktower, sabotages it, and accidentally brings the whole tower down.
Then the Keepers’ Interpreter of the prophecies, Caduca, is found murdered. Keeper Orland blames Garrett, rigs a trial and sends the elite Keeper Enforcers after him. With help from sympathetic Keepers, Garrett follows the clues to the Keeper library, where a mysterious old woman attacks him with Glyph magic. A Hammerite inspector identifies her as the Hag, a creature from folklore, and sends Garrett to the Shalebridge Cradle, a burned-out former orphanage and asylum and one of the most famous horror levels in gaming.
🧙 Who Is Gamall? The Deadly Shadows Ending Explained
Inside the Cradle, Garrett meets the ghost of a girl named Lauryl, who looks exactly like Gamall, Caduca’s young assistant and the girl Orland wants to make the new Interpreter. Garrett frees Lauryl’s spirit, escapes the Cradle by tricking it into believing he jumped to his death, and finds her tomb covered in Glyphs. The truth: Gamall is the Hag. She murdered Lauryl and stole her appearance with Glyph magic to rise to Interpreter, so she could use the Glyphs to destroy the Keepers. When Garrett breaks the Glyphs on the tomb, Gamall’s disguise falls apart during her own ceremony.
Gamall finds the Final Glyph, which can cancel all Glyph magic, and plans to destroy it. Garrett learns that the five Keeper artifacts must be placed at specific spots around the City to activate it, and steals the last ones from a museum. Outside, “Artemus” asks him to hand them over, but it is Gamall in disguise, and she kills Orland. Garrett places the artifacts himself, the Final Glyph ends all Glyph magic and Gamall withers into a powerless old woman.
In the final scene, a young girl tries to pick Garrett’s pocket. He catches her and repeats almost the same words Artemus once said to him. Many fans read this as Garrett finally taking on an apprentice and becoming a kind of Keeper himself, but the game leaves it open, so treat that as interpretation.
🔄 Thief (2014) Story Explained: Is the Reboot Connected?

The 2014 reboot follows a new Garrett in a plague-stricken City centuries later.
Thief (2014) by Eidos-Montréal is a reboot with a reimagined Garrett, but it is set in the same world, several hundred years after the original games. Documents and plaques reference the Keepers, the Hammerites and the old gods, and the original Garrett’s mechanical eye can even be found as hidden loot in a prison.
The story begins with Garrett and his reckless partner Erin robbing the manor of Baron Northcrest, the City’s tyrannical ruler, on a job arranged by Garrett’s fence Basso. On the roof, they see Northcrest leading a magical ritual. Garrett wants to call the job off, they struggle, and Erin falls through a skylight into the ritual, absorbing its energy. Garrett falls too and is knocked out.
He wakes up one year later. The City is ravaged by a plague called the Gloom, districts are locked down, and the Baron’s enforcer, the Thief-Taker General, rules the streets. Garrett works with Orion, leader of a resistance movement, and recovers pieces of a mysterious stone called the Primal, while visions show him that Erin is alive and under its power. His search leads him through the Moira Asylum and back to Northcrest, who reveals that his ritual was meant to harness the Primal as a new energy source. Its disruption shattered the stone and unleashed the Gloom.
The real villain is Orion, who is actually Aldous, Northcrest’s illegitimate brother, and who wants the Primal for himself. An informant called the Queen of Beggars tells Garrett the stone must be reassembled. Garrett kills the Thief-Taker General and chases Aldous to a ship, where Erin unleashes the Primal’s power and kills Aldous before turning on Garrett. He reassembles the stone and frees her, but she is thrown overboard. Garrett throws her his claw before passing out, and wakes to find it embedded in a post next to wet footprints, implying Erin survived.
🥽 Thief VR: Legacy of Shadow and Magpie
Thief VR: Legacy of Shadow, released on December 4, 2025 by Maze Theory and Vertigo Games, fills the gap between both eras. Lead designer Richard Bunn said it takes place between the original trilogy and the 2014 reboot, centuries before the latter. The heroine is Magpie, an orphan thief who finds the legendary Garrett’s mechanical eye. Once it attaches to her, Garrett’s voice, again performed by Stephen Russell, starts talking to her and guides her. Her enemy is a Baron Northcrest who rules the City through fear and hunts forbidden relics, while the Keepers are gone and only their Glyphs and secrets remain.
🎮 Thief Games in Chronological Order
- Thief: The Dark Project / Thief Gold (1998/1999), now remastered
- The Tarnished Mirror (2026), the remaster’s expansion, set after the Trickster’s defeat
- Thief II: The Metal Age (2000), about one year after the first game
- Thief: Deadly Shadows (2004), the end of the original trilogy
- Thief VR: Legacy of Shadow (2025), centuries later, between the trilogy and the reboot
- Thief (2014), the reboot, set several hundred years after the original games
If you are new to the series, start with the remaster on December 3. The Dark Project and The Metal Age form one continuous story, Deadly Shadows wraps up Garrett’s arc with the Keepers, and the 2014 reboot and Thief VR are optional side stories set much later.
❓ Quick Questions About the Thief Story
How did Garrett lose his eye?
In The Dark Project, Viktoria tears out his right eye so the Trickster can use it to power the Eye. Garrett later wears a mechanical replacement.
Is Constantine the Trickster?
Yes. The eccentric nobleman who hires Garrett is the Pagan god in disguise.
Does Viktoria die?
Yes, in Thief II, while carrying out her plan to trap Karras’ Servants inside the Mechanist cathedral.
Who is the Hag in Deadly Shadows?
Gamall, the young girl Orland wants to make the Keepers’ new Interpreter. She murdered Lauryl and stole her appearance.
Is Thief 2014 the same Garrett?
No. The 2014 Garrett is a new character in the same world, several hundred years later. The original Garrett’s mechanical eye appears as a hidden collectible.
Do I need to play the old games before the remaster?
No. The remaster is the first game, and its expansion leads directly toward Thief II.
Final Words
Thief’s story is quieter than most, told through stolen letters, overheard guards and a cynical narrator who never wanted to be a hero. Yet across three games, Garrett ends up saving the City from a nature god, a mad inventor and a Glyph-wielding monster, and finally passes on what Artemus once gave him. With the remaster and The Tarnished Mirror arriving on December 3, it is the perfect time to step back into the shadows. Want more stories from the shadows? Read our Half-Life story explained or our Wolfenstein story explained next.
Keep the adventure going! Check out more Gaming News on Gamersuniverse.
Picture Source: Nightdive Studios (Steam), Eidos / Square Enix (Steam), Eidos-Montréal / Square Enix (Steam)
